Choosing Your Deal Team: CPA, Attorney, and Whether You Need a Broker

What each advisor actually does in a sale, why M&A experience beats general practice, typical fee structures, and when a broker is genuinely optional.

Choosing Your Deal Team: CPA, Attorney, and Whether You Need a Broker

You’ll sell one company in your life, probably, and you’ll do it across the table from people who buy them for a living. That asymmetry is the entire case for a deal team, and it’s also the case for choosing it carefully, because the wrong advisors don’t just cost fees. They cost deals, months, and six-figure terms they didn’t know were negotiable. Here’s who does what, what each should cost, and the honest answer to the broker question, from a buyer who has sat across from every configuration.

The M&A attorney (not your attorney)

The lawyer who handled your lease and your LLC is not the lawyer for your sale, and the difference isn’t smarts. It’s pattern library. A transactional M&A attorney has seen a hundred purchase agreements, knows which reps and warranties are market-standard versus overreach, knows what an indemnity cap should be at your deal size, and (this is the part that saves real money) knows which fights matter. A generalist learning M&A on your deal re-litigates standard clauses (adding weeks) while missing the three nonstandard ones that carry actual risk. We’ve watched it from across the table, and it’s painful in both directions: the deal slows and the seller ends up worse protected.

What they do: negotiate the LOI’s fine print, run the legal side of diligence, draft and negotiate the purchase agreement, manage consents and closing mechanics. What it costs: hourly, commonly totaling in the tens of thousands on an MSP-sized deal ($25k to $75k is a fair planning band, complexity depending). Where to find one: ask other owners who sold, your state bar’s business-law section, or, honestly, ask the buyer’s side who they respect (good deal lawyers know each other). Interview two, and ask each: how many lower-middle-market transactions did you close in the past two years? Single digits is fine. Zero is your answer.

The CPA (early, and possibly upgraded)

Your CPA carries three jobs in a sale, and the first one starts years ahead: getting the books diligence-ready, the year-end discipline and addback documentation this series keeps returning to. The second is transaction tax strategy: asset versus stock, allocation, installment treatment, entity questions, the analysis that routinely swings six figures of net proceeds. The third is deal support: computing the working capital peg independently, sanity-checking the QoE’s adjustments, modeling each offer’s after-tax reality.

The honest question is whether your current CPA can do jobs two and three, because tax preparation and transaction tax are different specialties. The workable pattern for many sellers: keep your longtime CPA for the books and history, and bring in a transaction-tax specialist for a bounded engagement around the deal. Your CPA won’t be offended. The good ones suggest it first.

The broker question, answered honestly

A business broker or M&A advisor markets your company, runs a competitive process, and quarterbacks the transaction, typically for a success fee in the neighborhood of 8% to 12% at small-business scale (often on a sliding “Lehman-style” scale as deals grow), sometimes with upfront or monthly fees you should scrutinize hard. On a $3M deal, that’s roughly $250k to $350k. The question is what it buys, and the answer depends on your situation more than brokers or buyers like to admit.

A broker earns the fee when you don’t know who your buyers are, when competitive tension will genuinely move your price (a clean, desirable business that multiple platforms would fight over), when confidentiality requires an intermediary making blind approaches, or when you simply cannot run a months-long process and the business at the same time, a real failure mode with its own cost. A good advisor also filters tire-kickers and absorbs negotiating friction, keeping you out of adversarial moments with your eventual partner.

A broker is optional when you already know your likely buyer, or they know you. A direct conversation with a credible acquirer (a competitor you respect, a strategic in your region, an operator like us) can produce a fair deal without the fee, provided you replace the broker’s two real functions some other way: price discovery (get an independent valuation, run the workbook, talk to more than one buyer even informally) and process management (your attorney and CPA, engaged early, cover most of it). The trap in the direct path isn’t the missing broker. It’s the missing alternative: a seller with one buyer and no walk-away number negotiates from weakness regardless of who’s advising them. Solve that, and direct deals are how a large share of good small-market transactions actually happen.

The self-interest disclosure you should demand of any buyer writing on this topic: we do direct deals, so we benefit when sellers skip brokers. Which is why our actual advice is the neutral version: decide based on whether competition would move your price, and if you’re unsure, a two-or-three-buyer informal process (no broker, but no exclusivity either) often captures most of the tension at none of the fee.

Assembling the room

Sequence matters more than owners expect. CPA first, a year or more out. Attorney identified before you sign anything, even an NDA if it has odd terms. Broker decision made deliberately, not defaulted into by whoever calls you first. And one chair that stays empty until you fill it on purpose: the peer who sold, who charges nothing, reads situations rather than documents, and tells you which of your worries are normal at month four. Every good deal team we’ve sat across included one, officially or not.

The team’s total cost, brokered, might reach 12% of your deal; direct, perhaps 3%. Either way, the expensive version is the missing advisor: the standard clause nobody caught, the tax election nobody made, the peg nobody checked. Against those, good help is the cheapest line item in the transaction.

Talk to a buyer who'll say so